Skip to content
Shyenova

Industry 03

When a new site opens, do you know what it will take from the ones you already have?

The relevant number is never how much a new site will do. It is how much it will do that you were not already getting.

Consumer distribution decisions are made constantly and settled badly, because the analysis that would settle them properly is assumed to be harder than it is. Catchments are drawn as circles. Territories are inherited and defended. Inventory targets are set at portfolio level and applied uniformly across items whose variability differs by an order of magnitude.

Each of those is a solved problem with a well-understood method, and the gap between the casual answer and the correct one is usually large enough to change the decision. A drive-time catchment is typically fifteen to forty per cent smaller than the radius it replaces. Cannibalisation removes ten to thirty per cent of a new site's apparent revenue. And a cost-to-serve model almost always finds a prestigious, high-revenue account sitting firmly in negative territory.

What is changing

Four pressures worth naming.

Not a market overview. These are the specific things that make the standard answer wrong in this sector right now.

01Pressure

Quick commerce changed the footprint question

Delivery-radius constraints turn network design into a coverage problem with a hard operational bound, and the number of sites needed to cover a city at a promised delivery time is a facility location problem rather than a property one.

02Pressure

Assortment complexity outgrew the planning parameters

Portfolios expanded; the segmentation behind safety stock did not. A single service target across items with wildly different demand patterns is wrong for every one of them.

03Pressure

Service costs are pooled and therefore invisible

Allocating distribution cost as a percentage of revenue guarantees the answer is wrong in a predictable direction, and conceals exactly the accounts where the answer matters.

04Pressure

Promotional intensity manufactures its own volatility

A large share of the demand variability these businesses plan against is generated by their own commercial calendar rather than by the market.

Questions

About consumer & retail.

Do we need to buy footfall or mobility data?

Rarely at the outset. Your own transaction data geocoded to customer origin is usually more informative than purchased mobility data, and you already own it. Commercial footfall data earns its cost in high-street retail where passing trade dominates; for destination formats and distribution it generally does not.

Will taking inventory out hurt service?

It should not, and if the sequencing is right service improves first. The initial tranche comes from stock demonstrably protecting against nothing, dead cover, duplicated buffers across echelons, pre-build for a seasonality that no longer exists. Service-relevant stock is often increased in the same programme, at a different echelon and in a less finished form.

Our field team will resist a territory redesign.

They usually will, and usually for rational reasons, someone is losing accounts they built. We model the disruption of each individual move, drop the ones costing a lot of goodwill for little gain, and give management the numbers for the ones worth doing anyway. A mathematically optimal design implemented against the field's will underperforms a slightly worse one they accept.

Start a conversation

Talk to us about consumer & retail.

Most useful first conversations are thirty minutes and involve no proposal. Describe the problem you are looking at and we will tell you honestly whether it is one we can help with.

Or write directly to hello@shyenova.com