Supply Chain & Analytics
Control Towers
Supply chain technology spend has an uncomfortable success rate. The pattern is consistent: a capability gap is identified, a platform is selected against a requirements list assembled from vendor materials, implementation runs long, and the organisation ends up with a more expensive version of the process it had before.
The failure is almost never the software. It is that the decision the technology was meant to improve was never specified precisely enough to test whether it improved. We start from the decision, who makes it, on what information, how often, and what would have to be different for a better one to be made, and work backwards to what, if anything, needs to be bought.
How the work runs
Four phases, and what comes out of each.
2 weeks
Start from the decision
We inventory the decisions that actually move cost and service (replenishment quantity, allocation under shortage, mode selection, capacity commitment) and for each one establish who decides, on what information, at what cadence, and where the current answer is demonstrably suboptimal. Technology requirements that do not trace to a decision on this list do not survive the exercise.
Outputs
- Decision inventory with owners, cadence and current information basis
- Value-at-stake per decision
- Requirements traced to specific decision improvements
2–3 weeks
Assess the data foundation honestly
Every advanced capability rests on master data, and master data is where most programmes quietly fail. We profile the actual state of item, location, supplier and bill-of-material data against what the intended capability requires, and we are specific about what must be fixed first. This is unglamorous and it is the difference between a working system and an expensive one.
Outputs
- Data quality profile against capability requirements
- Prioritised remediation plan with effort estimates
- Data governance model with named ownership
4–6 weeks
Select, or decide not to buy
Where a genuine gap exists we run a structured selection: requirements weighted by value at stake, scripted demonstrations using your own data rather than the vendor's, reference calls with clients at comparable scale and complexity, and total cost of ownership modelled over five years including the implementation partner. Frequently the recommendation is to buy less than was originally scoped.
Outputs
- Weighted requirements and evaluation framework
- Scripted vendor demonstrations on your data
- Five-year total cost of ownership comparison and recommendation
4–8 weeks
Build the decision layer
Where the answer is analytics rather than a platform, we build it: exception-driven control tower views, alerting tuned to actionable thresholds rather than everything unusual, and decision support that presents a recommended action with its reasoning instead of a chart requiring interpretation. Built with your team, in your stack, so it is maintainable after we leave.
Outputs
- Exception-based control tower with tuned alerting
- Decision support tooling with recommended actions
- Handover, documentation and analyst enablement
What good looks like
The ranges we design toward.
30–50%
Scope reduction
Typical trim to originally-scoped software requirements once traced to actual decisions.
70–90%
Alert volume
Reduction once alerting is tuned to actionable exceptions rather than statistical anomalies.
0
Software commissions
We hold no vendor partnerships and take no referral fees. It is why the recommendation is worth reading.
Deliverables
What you are left holding.
- 01Decision inventory with quantified value at stake per decision
- 02Honest data readiness assessment and prioritised remediation plan
- 03Independent system selection with five-year total cost of ownership
- 04Working control tower or decision-support tooling built in your stack
- 05Capability handover so your team maintains what we built
What an engagement looks like
A representative shape.
Illustrative. This is the shape of work in supply chain & analytics, not an account of a specific client. We do not publish named results, and we would be wary of a firm that publishes them without the client in the room.
12 weeks
- 01Situation
A consumer goods manufacturer was opening a third distribution centre on the strength of a regional sales forecast, with freight cost per unit rising and no cost-to-serve view below channel level.
- 02What we did
Reconstructed eighteen months of shipment data into a true origin–destination model, built cost-to-serve to customer level, and tested the proposed footprint against demand growth, rate shock and node-loss scenarios.
- 03Where it landed
The third site turned out to be robust only under the most optimistic growth case. Redrawing catchments and re-tendering two lanes captured most of the projected saving without the capital, and the site decision was deferred rather than cancelled.
Questions
The ones we get asked.
Do you implement the systems you recommend?
No, deliberately. An adviser who also sells the implementation has an interest in a larger implementation. We will help you write the statement of work, evaluate systems integrators and govern the programme, but the build is done by someone whose incentives we do not share.
Everyone is selling AI for supply chain. Is any of it real?
Some of it, in specific places. Machine learning genuinely outperforms classical methods for intermittent demand, promotional response and lead-time prediction where you have sufficient history. It underperforms badly on sparse data, structural breaks and anything requiring causal reasoning about a situation with no precedent. The useful question is never whether the technique is advanced. It is whether the decision it feeds is currently being made badly and whether the data exists to make it better.
Our master data is a mess. Should we fix that before anything else?
Fix it for the capability you are actually building, not universally. Enterprise-wide data remediation programmes run for years and lose sponsorship before delivering value. Scoped to the specific fields a defined capability requires, the same work takes months and pays for itself, and the governance habits it establishes then extend naturally.
What is a control tower actually supposed to do?
Reduce the time between something going wrong and someone competent doing something about it. If it does not shorten that interval it is a reporting layer with an ambitious name. The design test we apply is simple: for every view, name the decision it triggers and the person who makes it. Views that fail that test get cut.
Insights
Related reading.
The bullwhip effect: why your demand signal lies
Factory schedules swing by forty per cent while end-consumer demand moves by five. Nobody is behaving irrationally. That is precisely the problem.
Multi-echelon inventory: beyond the safety stock formula
The standard safety stock formula is correct and it is answering a question nobody in a multi-tier network is actually asking.
Cost-to-serve: the analysis most companies skip
Most businesses know their gross margin by customer. Rather fewer know which customers are profitable, and the two lists differ more than anyone expects.
S&OP versus IBP: what actually changes
Most descriptions of the difference are vendor taxonomy. The distinction that matters is whether a trade-off gets settled by someone with the authority to settle it.
Why people systematically under-order high-margin products
The mathematics of a single-period stocking decision is a hundred years old and unambiguous. Experienced buyers still get it wrong in the same direction, every time.
Closely related
More on Supply Chain & Analytics →Demand & Inventory Planning
One demand number the business will commit to, and an inventory policy that follows from it rather than from a rule of thumb.
Supply Chain & AnalyticsLogistics & Distribution
Freight cost, warehouse productivity and 3PL performance, measured properly, then fixed at the root.
Supply Chain & AnalyticsData Foundations
The unglamorous layer everything else rests on, pipelines, models, tests and lineage, scoped to a capability rather than to the whole enterprise.
Start a conversation
Talk to us about control towers.
Most useful first conversations are thirty minutes and involve no proposal. Describe the problem you are looking at and we will tell you honestly whether it is one we can help with.
Or write directly to hello@shyenova.com
