Skip to content
Shyenova

Carbon Trading

Carbon Markets

Being long or short carbon is a position, whether or not anybody in the business has decided to take one. The market prices it either way.

As compliance carbon markets mature, an obligated entity holds a position in an instrument with a fluctuating price and a hard annual surrender date. That position exists whether or not anybody has consciously taken it. Most organisations discover this at the first compliance deadline, buy in a thin market under time pressure, and pay for the privilege.

The alternative is to treat it as what it is: a portfolio question sitting on top of an operational one. How much will we be short, given the abatement we will actually complete? At what price does abating beat surrendering? What is the cheapest defensible way to cover the remainder, and when? These are answerable in advance, and answering them is worth considerably more than any view on where the price is going.

How the work runs

Four phases, and what comes out of each.

Durations are indicative and assume reasonable data availability. Where data is poor we say so in the first fortnight rather than modelling on sand.
01

2–3 weeks

Establish the obligation and the exposure

We work out precisely what the mechanism requires of you (coverage, baseline, intensity target, surrender obligation and timing) and model the position across production and abatement scenarios. Most organisations discover their exposure is either materially larger or materially smaller than assumed, and both are expensive surprises.

Outputs

  • Obligation mapped against the applicable mechanism and timeline
  • Position modelled across production and abatement scenarios
  • Compliance calendar with the decisions each date forces
02

2–3 weeks

Set the abate-versus-surrender line

The central decision is where abatement stops being cheaper than compliance. That line comes straight off the abatement curve intersected with the certificate price, and it converts a strategic-sounding question into an arithmetic one. Below the line, abate. Above it, surrender. The interesting work is in the uncertainty around where the line sits.

Outputs

  • Abate-versus-surrender threshold with the reasoning behind it
  • Sensitivity to certificate price, production volume and project delivery
  • Recommended split between abatement and market coverage
03

3–4 weeks

Assess what you would be buying

In the voluntary market especially, credits differ enormously in integrity, and buying on price alone is how organisations end up defending a purchase in public. We assess against additionality, permanence, leakage, baseline conservatism, double-counting risk and the standard's own track record, and we take no fee on any transaction, which is why the assessment is worth reading.

Outputs

  • Quality framework calibrated to your risk tolerance
  • Assessment of candidate credit types and standards
  • Documented rationale that would survive public challenge
04

2–3 weeks

Put a governance around it

A position needs an owner, a mandate and limits, exactly as any other commodity exposure does. We define who may transact, within what bounds, on what approval, with what reporting, and where a project of yours could generate credits, we assess qualification honestly rather than optimistically.

Outputs

  • Governance with named ownership, mandate and limits
  • Procurement and timing approach for the coverage required
  • Credit generation potential assessed where relevant

What good looks like

The ranges we design toward.

These are the improvement ranges these levers are known to produce where the underlying practice has not been examined recently. They are targets to test against your baseline, not promises.

10–30%

Deadline premium

Typical price penalty for covering a compliance position in a thin market close to surrender.

Wide

Voluntary credit price spread

Prices for a nominal tonne differ by an order of magnitude across project types. Quality, not arbitrage, explains most of it.

0

Transaction fees to us

We take no position and earn nothing on any credit discussed. In this market that is the whole basis of the advice.

Deliverables

What you are left holding.

All of it handed over, documented, and with a session for whoever inherits it.
  1. 01Obligation and exposure modelled across production and abatement scenarios
  2. 02Abate-versus-surrender threshold, with the sensitivities that move it
  3. 03Credit quality framework and assessment of candidate types
  4. 04Governance with named ownership, mandate and transaction limits
  5. 05Honest assessment of whether your own projects would qualify to generate credits

What an engagement looks like

A representative shape.

Illustrative. This is the shape of work in carbon trading, not an account of a specific client. We do not publish named results, and we would be wary of a firm that publishes them without the client in the room.

14 weeks

  1. 01Situation

    A cement producer entering the compliance market as an obligated entity could not say how short it would be at the first surrender date. The inventory had been built on spend factors, and a list of decarbonisation projects existed with no cost per tonne attached to any of them.

  2. 02What we did

    Rebuilt the inventory on activity data, costed every abatement option as levelised cost per tonne abated, and modelled the position across production, project-delivery and certificate-price scenarios to establish where abating stopped being cheaper than surrendering.

  3. 03Where it landed

    The rebuilt inventory moved the projected shortfall materially. Several measures abated below the plausible certificate price and went into the capital plan ahead of any purchase. Coverage for the remainder was scheduled through the year against a mandate with named ownership and transaction limits, rather than bought in a thin market in the closing weeks.

Where this connects

Rarely a self-contained problem.

These are the adjacencies that come up most often on this kind of work. Naming them is usually cheaper than discovering them halfway through.

Questions

The ones we get asked.

Is a carbon credit the same as a compliance certificate?

No, and conflating them causes real problems. A compliance instrument is issued under a regulatory scheme and surrendered against a legal obligation. A voluntary credit represents a claimed reduction outside any compliance obligation. Some schemes allow limited use of offset credits against compliance and most constrain it tightly. Which instruments satisfy which obligation is a scheme-specific question that has to be checked rather than assumed.

How do we know a credit represents a real tonne?

You establish it, or you accept you have not. The questions are whether the reduction would have happened anyway, whether it is durable, whether it displaced emissions elsewhere, whether the baseline is conservative, and whether anyone else is also claiming it. Different project types score very differently, and price correlates with these far more than most buyers expect. The cheap credit is usually cheap for a reason a journalist can find.

Should we generate credits from our own projects?

Sometimes, and the assessment should be sober. Registration, validation, monitoring and verification carry real cost and multi-year timelines, and additionality is the binding test. A project you would have done anyway generally does not qualify, which excludes most of the attractive-looking candidates. Where it works, it works well; the honest screen is short.

Do you trade or broker credits?

No. We hold no position, take no fee on any transaction and have no relationship with any developer or exchange. A large share of carbon market advice is issued by parties who also sell the product, and this is the one thing that makes ours different in kind.

Start a conversation

Talk to us about carbon markets.

Most useful first conversations are thirty minutes and involve no proposal. Describe the problem you are looking at and we will tell you honestly whether it is one we can help with.

Or write directly to hello@shyenova.com