Carbon Trading
Carbon Accounting
Most first emissions inventories are built the fastest way available: take spend by category, multiply by a published factor, sum. It produces a number quickly and the number is almost entirely a restatement of how much you spent. Buy the same steel from a supplier running on renewables and the figure does not move, which tells you the measurement cannot see the thing you would actually change.
An inventory that supports decisions has to be built on activity (tonnes consumed, kilowatt-hours drawn, kilometres moved) with supplier-specific factors where the emissions are concentrated. It takes longer, it is the only version that survives assurance, and it is the one that tells you where abatement is worth attempting.
How the work runs
Four phases, and what comes out of each.
1–2 weeks
Set the boundary before counting anything
Organisational boundary (equity share, financial or operational control) and operational boundary determine what is in scope, and choosing them casually causes restatements later. We set them explicitly against the standards you report under, and document which entities and facilities are consolidated and why.
Outputs
- Organisational and operational boundary, documented with the consolidation basis
- Entity and facility register with inclusion rationale
- Base year set, with a recalculation policy for structural change
3–4 weeks
Build Scope 1 and 2 on real activity
Direct combustion, process emissions, refrigerants and purchased energy, built from meter and consumption data rather than invoices where the two differ. Scope 2 is reported on both location-based and market-based methods, because they can differ enormously and the choice changes what an abatement decision looks like.
Outputs
- Scope 1 by source with activity data and factor provenance
- Scope 2 on both location-based and market-based methods
- Data quality tier assigned per stream, with gaps stated
4–6 weeks
Attack Scope 3 where it concentrates
Scope 3 has fifteen categories and for most organisations two or three carry the overwhelming majority, usually purchased goods, upstream transport and use of sold products. We screen all fifteen to establish materiality, then build the material ones on supplier-specific data and the rest on documented secondary factors, labelling clearly which is which.
Outputs
- Materiality screen across all fifteen categories
- Material categories built on supplier-specific or activity data
- Primary versus secondary data explicitly labelled per category
2–3 weeks
Build the evidence pack, then hand it over
Verification fails on traceability far more often than on method. Every figure is traceable to a source document, every factor to a cited source and vintage, every estimate to a stated assumption. Then the calculation is handed over as something your team runs annually rather than something they commission.
Outputs
- Evidence pack with full traceability from figure to source
- Re-runnable calculation model with documentation
- Annual process with named owners and a review cadence
What good looks like
The ranges we design toward.
20–40%
Restatement on rebuild
Typical change when a spend-based inventory is rebuilt on activity data. It moves in both directions.
2–3
Material Scope 3 categories
How many of the fifteen usually carry the great majority for a manufacturer.
1 source
Serving every obligation
One inventory feeding compliance, CBAM, customer disclosure and abatement planning.
Deliverables
What you are left holding.
- 01Documented boundary, base year and recalculation policy
- 02Full Scope 1, 2 and 3 inventory with data quality tiering per stream
- 03Emission factor register with source and vintage for every factor used
- 04Evidence pack traceable end to end, built for third-party verification
- 05Re-runnable model handed to your team with an annual process around it
What an engagement looks like
A representative shape.
Illustrative. This is the shape of work in carbon trading, not an account of a specific client. We do not publish named results, and we would be wary of a firm that publishes them without the client in the room.
14 weeks
- 01Situation
A cement producer entering the compliance market as an obligated entity could not say how short it would be at the first surrender date. The inventory had been built on spend factors, and a list of decarbonisation projects existed with no cost per tonne attached to any of them.
- 02What we did
Rebuilt the inventory on activity data, costed every abatement option as levelised cost per tonne abated, and modelled the position across production, project-delivery and certificate-price scenarios to establish where abating stopped being cheaper than surrendering.
- 03Where it landed
The rebuilt inventory moved the projected shortfall materially. Several measures abated below the plausible certificate price and went into the capital plan ahead of any purchase. Coverage for the remainder was scheduled through the year against a mandate with named ownership and transaction limits, rather than bought in a thin market in the closing weeks.
Where this connects
Rarely a self-contained problem.
Supply Chain Resilience
Scope 3 and multi-tier resilience need the same thing first, knowing where your supply base physically is. Doing both from one mapping exercise halves the cost of either.
Supply Chain & AnalyticsData Foundations
An inventory that has to be reproduced annually and survive audit is a data pipeline problem, and benefits from the same lineage and testing discipline.
Questions
The ones we get asked.
How long does a first inventory take?
For a single site with reasonable metering, six to eight weeks including Scope 3 screening. For a multi-site group with poor data, a quarter or more, and most of that time is data collection rather than calculation. We would rather scope it to one site done properly than an entire group done thinly, because the second cannot be verified.
Which standard should we report under?
GHG Protocol underlies almost everything and is the sensible foundation regardless of what sits on top. What varies is the disclosure framework your stakeholders require and any sector-specific methodology that binds you. Establish that first, building generically and retrofitting usually means redoing the boundary, which is the expensive part.
Our suppliers will not give us emissions data. What then?
Most will not at first, and a blanket questionnaire to the whole base reliably fails. Concentrate on the suppliers who carry the emissions (usually a small number) and make the request specific and reciprocal. For the rest, documented secondary factors are legitimate provided the inventory says plainly which categories are estimated. Pretending otherwise is what gets caught in assurance.
Can you produce product-level footprints?
Yes, once the site inventory exists and allocation rules are agreed. Allocation is where product footprints get contested (between co-products, across shared utilities, over joint processes) so the rules need setting explicitly and consistently rather than per customer request. This is also the input CBAM requires.
Insights
Related reading.
What CBAM actually asks of an exporter
It is usually described as a carbon tax at the EU border. For a producer it behaves much more like an evidence problem, and the exporters paying most are frequently the ones emitting least.
Pricing supply chain resilience
Every disruption produces a resolution to become more resilient. Almost every resolution dies quietly at the next budget cycle, for a reason that is entirely predictable.
Closely related
More on Carbon Trading →Decarbonisation
Every abatement option ranked by cost per tonne, so the capital plan follows the curve rather than the enthusiasm.
Carbon TradingCarbon Border Compliance
Embedded emissions established at product level, so exporters pay for the carbon they actually emit rather than a punitive default.
Start a conversation
Talk to us about carbon accounting.
Most useful first conversations are thirty minutes and involve no proposal. Describe the problem you are looking at and we will tell you honestly whether it is one we can help with.
Or write directly to hello@shyenova.com
