Skip to content
Shyenova

Maritime Carbon

FuelEU Compliance & Pooling

FuelEU rewards a ship that beats its intensity limit and charges one that misses it. Pooling makes those two ships the same balance sheet.

FuelEU Maritime has applied since 1 January 2025 to ships above 5,000 gross tonnage calling at EU ports, regardless of flag. It limits the greenhouse gas intensity of the energy used on board, against a 2020 baseline: 2% lower from 2025, then 6% from 2030, 14.5% from 2035, 31% from 2040, 62% from 2045 and 80% from 2050. A ship ends each year with a compliance balance, positive if it beat the limit and negative if it missed it.

The regulation provides ways to manage that balance. A surplus can be banked for the same ship's later use. A deficit can be borrowed against the following year within limits. Ships, including ships of different companies, can pool their balances. The remaining deficit is charged a penalty. Choosing among those routes is an optimisation across a fleet and over time, and the cheapest answer is rarely the obvious one.

How the work runs

Four phases, and what comes out of each.

Durations are indicative and assume reasonable data availability. Where data is poor we say so in the first fortnight rather than modelling on sand.
01

2–3 weeks

Forecast each ship's balance

From the voyage plan, fuel plan and fuel model, we forecast each ship's greenhouse gas intensity and compliance balance for the year, updated as fixtures and bunkering change, and project it through the coming step changes in the limit.

Outputs

  • Compliance balance forecast per ship
  • Projection through the 2030 and later steps
  • Sensitivity to fuel and trade assumptions
02

2–3 weeks

Compare every route to compliance

Fuel change, banking, borrowing, pooling and paying the penalty are each priced for each ship, including what a surplus is worth if kept rather than sold. The comparison is done with your costs, not with the price a pool provider quotes.

Outputs

  • Cost of each compliance route by ship
  • Value of banking against selling surplus
  • Borrowing limits and conditions applied correctly
03

3–4 weeks

Design the pool

Where pooling is the answer, we work out which ships to pool and how to allocate surplus within the pool's rules, whether within your own fleet or with other companies. Pool allocation is a small optimisation problem with rules attached, and it is solved as one.

Outputs

  • Pool composition and allocation
  • Terms to require of external pool partners
  • Verification and registration timeline
04

2 weeks

Tie it into fuel and fleet plans

The FuelEU position is linked into bunker planning and fleet decisions so it is managed through the year rather than settled after it. The model is handed over and run by your team.

Outputs

  • Balance forecast linked to bunker and voyage planning
  • Fleet plan implications of later limit steps
  • Model and documentation handed over

What good looks like

The ranges we design toward.

These are the improvement ranges these levers are known to produce where the underlying practice has not been examined recently. They are targets to test against your baseline, not promises.

2 → 80%

Intensity reduction, 2025 to 2050

Against a 2020 baseline, in steps: 2%, 6%, 14.5%, 31%, 62% and 80%.

€2,400

Penalty per tonne

Charged per tonne of VLSFO energy equivalent of the deficit, increasing for consecutive years of non-compliance.

Cross-company

Pooling allowed

Ships of different companies can pool their balances, so a surplus has value beyond the fleet that earned it.

Deliverables

What you are left holding.

All of it handed over, documented, and with a session for whoever inherits it.
  1. 01Compliance balance forecast per ship, projected through later limit steps
  2. 02Costed comparison of fuel change, banking, borrowing, pooling and penalty
  3. 03Pool design and allocation where pooling is chosen
  4. 04Link from FuelEU position to bunker and fleet plans
  5. 05Model owned and run by your team

What an engagement looks like

A representative shape.

Illustrative. This is the shape of work in maritime carbon, not an account of a specific client. We do not publish named results, and we would be wary of a firm that publishes them without the client in the room.

12 weeks

  1. 01Situation

    A dry bulk operator with part of its fleet trading into Europe had its first EU ETS surrender approaching and no view of its FuelEU balance. Speed instructions were set commercially per voyage, bunkering was decided by price alone, and the CII rating for each ship was discovered after year end.

  2. 02What we did

    Fitted a speed and fuel model for each ship from its own reports, built one emissions dataset serving MRV, ETS, FuelEU and CII from the same fuel records, and priced allowance and FuelEU cost into the voyage evaluation used for fixtures, with a rolling CII forecast per ship.

  3. 03Where it landed

    Carbon cost appeared in the voyage estimate before fixing rather than in the accounts afterwards. Two ships heading for a D rating were identified early enough to act within the year. Allowance purchasing moved from a single deadline purchase to a schedule under a written mandate, and the models were handed to the operator's own team.

Questions

The ones we get asked.

Should we join a pool or bank our surplus?

It depends on the price offered, what the surplus would be worth to your own ships in later years as the limit tightens, and how certain those later deficits are. A surplus sold now cannot be used later. We price both against your own fleet plan rather than against a pool provider's quote.

Can we borrow against next year?

Within limits. A deficit can be borrowed against the following year, the amount is capped, the borrowed amount is increased when repaid, and borrowing cannot be repeated in consecutive years or combined with pooling in the same year. It is a useful bridge and an expensive habit.

Do you operate a pool?

No. We do not run, broker or take a fee from any pool. That is why we can tell you whether a pool offer is a good one.

Start a conversation

Talk to us about fueleu compliance & pooling.

Most useful first conversations are thirty minutes and involve no proposal. Describe the problem you are looking at and we will tell you honestly whether it is one we can help with.

Or write directly to hello@shyenova.com