Skip to content
Shyenova

Industry 07

How do you measure a programme spread across an area nobody can survey?

Area-wide measurement used to mean sampling and extrapolating hard. The archive now covers every district, every fortnight, back forty years.

Public programmes are frequently evaluated on reported activity rather than observed outcome, because observing the outcome across the whole area was historically impossible. Trees planted is countable; trees surviving is not, unless somebody walks the site. Area brought under irrigation is reported; area actually irrigated is measured only where an inspector went.

Satellite observation removes that constraint for a wide class of programme outcomes, and does so retrospectively, a baseline for a date that has already passed can be reconstructed from the archive. What it demands in return is honesty about accuracy: a change map is the difference between two classifications, so its errors compound, and any figure presented without a stated confidence will eventually be challenged by someone who knows that.

What is changing

Four pressures worth naming.

Not a market overview. These are the specific things that make the standard answer wrong in this sector right now.

01Pressure

Reporting measures activity, not outcome

Programmes are assessed on inputs and reported completion because the outcome was not observable at scale. It now is, for a substantial class of land, water and vegetation outcomes.

02Pressure

Records and ground truth have diverged

Land records and what is physically present drift apart over decades, and nobody can say by how much without a systematic comparison.

03Pressure

Departments hold conflicting geometry

The same administrative boundary commonly exists in several differing versions, so two departments analysing the same area reach different answers and neither can reconcile them.

04Pressure

Evaluation happens once and then ages

Assessments are commissioned as one-off studies rather than built as re-runnable pipelines, so each successive cycle pays to rebuild what already existed.

Questions

About public & development.

How far back can a baseline be reconstructed?

To the mid-1980s at thirty-metre resolution using the Landsat archive, which is free and global. Finer ten-metre Sentinel-2 data begins in 2015, so a long series is usually a coarser one, and where a study spans both, the sensor change has to be calibrated for explicitly rather than assumed away.

Can this be used as evidence in a dispute?

Generally as corroborating evidence, rarely as sufficient on its own. Satellite change detection has a stated error rate and opposing counsel will find it. We structure outputs accordingly, high-confidence detections separated from marginal ones, full provenance for every scene, documented methodology, so it directs where a surveyor goes rather than replacing them.

We have an existing GIS department. What is the division of labour?

Usually classification and validation methodology from us, mapping and operation from them. Many capable teams have never had to defend an accuracy assessment or propagate error through a change product. We frequently build one epoch or one cycle with the team and hand the rest over, documented and re-runnable.

Start a conversation

Talk to us about public & development.

Most useful first conversations are thirty minutes and involve no proposal. Describe the problem you are looking at and we will tell you honestly whether it is one we can help with.

Or write directly to hello@shyenova.com