Carbon Trading
Decarbonisation
Decarbonisation planning goes wrong in a predictable way. The options that get attention are the visible ones (a solar installation, an electric fleet, a hydrogen study) because they are legible to a board. The options that actually move tonnes per rupee are usually duller: a compressed air leak survey, a heat recovery loop, a motor replacement programme, a process control change.
A marginal abatement cost curve settles this by ranking every option by cost per tonne abated, which converts an argument about priorities into a sequencing decision. The unglamorous finding, repeated across almost every first curve we build, is that a substantial share of available abatement sits at negative cost and is not being done.
How the work runs
Four phases, and what comes out of each.
1–2 weeks
Start from a measured baseline
A curve built on an unreliable inventory ranks the wrong things. We start from a measured baseline broken down far enough to attach abatement options to specific sources (by site, process and energy carrier) rather than to an organisation-level total that nothing can be attached to.
Outputs
- Baseline disaggregated to the level abatement attaches to
- Energy and emissions balance by site and process
- Business-as-usual trajectory before any intervention
3–4 weeks
Build the option set exhaustively
Options are collected from process engineering, energy management, procurement and operations, not only from the sustainability function, which is why the boring high-return measures usually surface here for the first time. Each is specified enough to cost: capital, operating change, tonnes abated per year, lifetime.
Outputs
- Option register spanning process, energy, materials and procurement
- Each option specified to a costable level
- Interactions and mutual exclusivity flagged between options
2–3 weeks
Cost it per tonne and rank it
Each option is costed as levelised cost per tonne abated over its lifetime, netting operating savings, and plotted as a curve. Options below the axis pay for themselves. The curve is then tested across carbon price scenarios, because what is uneconomic at one price becomes obvious at another and the capital plan should know where those thresholds sit.
Outputs
- Marginal abatement cost curve with every option ranked
- Sensitivity to carbon price, energy price and utilisation
- Threshold analysis showing where each option turns economic
2–3 weeks
Sequence it against real constraints
The curve gives the ranking; the plan has to respect capital availability, outage windows, engineering capacity and the fact that some measures foreclose others. We build the sequenced roadmap and, importantly, identify which decisions can wait and which have a closing window because of asset replacement cycles.
Outputs
- Sequenced roadmap against capital and outage constraints
- Decisions with a closing window flagged explicitly
- Residual emissions after the plan, which is what credits would address
What good looks like
The ranges we design toward.
30–60%
Abatement at negative cost
Share of a first curve that pays for itself before any carbon price is applied.
2–4×
Cost spread
Typical difference in cost per tonne between the cheapest and most-discussed options.
10–20 yr
Decision windows
Asset replacement cycles that quietly foreclose options if a decision is deferred past them.
Deliverables
What you are left holding.
- 01Disaggregated baseline and business-as-usual trajectory
- 02Exhaustive option register spanning process, energy, materials and procurement
- 03Marginal abatement cost curve with carbon price sensitivities
- 04Sequenced roadmap respecting capital, outage and engineering constraints
- 05Residual emissions figure, the only part a credit purchase should address
What an engagement looks like
A representative shape.
Illustrative. This is the shape of work in carbon trading, not an account of a specific client. We do not publish named results, and we would be wary of a firm that publishes them without the client in the room.
14 weeks
- 01Situation
A cement producer entering the compliance market as an obligated entity could not say how short it would be at the first surrender date. The inventory had been built on spend factors, and a list of decarbonisation projects existed with no cost per tonne attached to any of them.
- 02What we did
Rebuilt the inventory on activity data, costed every abatement option as levelised cost per tonne abated, and modelled the position across production, project-delivery and certificate-price scenarios to establish where abating stopped being cheaper than surrendering.
- 03Where it landed
The rebuilt inventory moved the projected shortfall materially. Several measures abated below the plausible certificate price and went into the capital plan ahead of any purchase. Coverage for the remainder was scheduled through the year against a mandate with named ownership and transaction limits, rather than bought in a thin market in the closing weeks.
Where this connects
Rarely a self-contained problem.
Questions
The ones we get asked.
If a third of it pays for itself, why has nobody done it?
Because those measures are small, distributed, unglamorous and belong to no single budget holder. A compressed air leak survey has an excellent return and no sponsor. The curve is useful precisely because it makes those measures visible next to the large ones and forces the question of why the cheap tonnes are not being taken first.
What carbon price should we plan against?
Several, which is the point of the sensitivity analysis. A single assumed price makes the plan hostage to a forecast nobody can make. We identify the threshold at which each option turns economic, which tells you what to commit to now and what to keep specified and ready.
Does this include offsets?
Only for residual emissions after the abatement plan, and it is deliberately the last step. Offsets are frequently more expensive per tonne than abatement measures already sitting unexecuted on the curve, and always more exposed to reputational and regulatory challenge. Establish the residual first, then decide.
Our emissions are mostly Scope 3. Does an abatement curve still work?
Yes, and it changes shape. The levers become supplier selection, material substitution, design change and specification rather than plant investment, and the costing must reflect that many are commercial decisions rather than capital ones. It is a harder curve to build and often a more valuable one, because Scope 3 abatement is where most manufacturers have made no attempt at all.
Insights
Related reading.
What CBAM actually asks of an exporter
It is usually described as a carbon tax at the EU border. For a producer it behaves much more like an evidence problem, and the exporters paying most are frequently the ones emitting least.
Pricing supply chain resilience
Every disruption produces a resolution to become more resilient. Almost every resolution dies quietly at the next budget cycle, for a reason that is entirely predictable.
Closely related
More on Carbon Trading →Carbon Accounting
A Scope 1, 2 and 3 inventory built on activity data rather than spend factors, one measurement that serves every obligation.
Carbon TradingCarbon Markets
The obligation modelled across scenarios, the abate-versus-surrender line drawn on your own curve, and a quality bar for anything you buy.
Start a conversation
Talk to us about decarbonisation.
Most useful first conversations are thirty minutes and involve no proposal. Describe the problem you are looking at and we will tell you honestly whether it is one we can help with.
Or write directly to hello@shyenova.com
