Skip to content
Shyenova

Carbon Trading

Carbon Border Compliance

Default values are set conservatively by design. Exporters using them are usually paying for emissions they do not have.

The EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism prices the carbon embedded in imported goods in covered categories (iron and steel, aluminium, cement, fertilisers, hydrogen and electricity) bringing them into line with what EU producers pay. For exporters in those categories it converts an environmental externality into a landed cost that varies by how the goods were actually made.

The mechanism permits actual embedded emissions to be used in place of default values, and permits deduction of a carbon price already paid in the country of production. Both require evidence at product level to a specified methodology. Exporters who cannot produce that evidence fall back on defaults set deliberately conservatively, which is to say, high. For a producer running efficiently, the gap between their real emissions and the default is money paid for nothing.

How the work runs

Four phases, and what comes out of each.

Durations are indicative and assume reasonable data availability. Where data is poor we say so in the first fortnight rather than modelling on sand.
01

1–2 weeks

Establish exposure precisely

Which of your goods fall in covered categories, under which classifications, in what volumes, to which importers, and therefore what the obligation actually is and who bears it. This is more often ambiguous than expected, particularly for downstream and composite products, and getting it wrong in either direction is costly.

Outputs

  • Covered goods identified by classification and volume
  • Obligation and its allocation between exporter and importer
  • Baseline cost exposure under default values
02

4–6 weeks

Measure embedded emissions at product level

Direct and, where applicable, indirect emissions attributable to the specific goods, calculated per the required methodology with production-route detail and defensible allocation between co-products. Allocation is where these calculations are most often challenged, so the rules are set explicitly and applied consistently rather than chosen per shipment.

Outputs

  • Product-level embedded emissions by production route
  • Allocation methodology documented and applied consistently
  • Precursor and input emissions traced where the methodology requires
03

2–3 weeks

Claim what is deductible

Carbon price already paid in the country of production is deductible, and claiming it requires evidence of the price paid and of its non-refund. As domestic compliance markets mature this deduction becomes materially larger, and organisations that have not built the evidence trail cannot claim it retrospectively.

Outputs

  • Deductible carbon price quantified with supporting evidence
  • Evidence trail structured for verification
  • Net exposure after deduction, per product and route
04

2–3 weeks

Make it a process, and price it into contracts

The obligation recurs, so the calculation becomes a repeating process with the data collected as production happens rather than reconstructed at deadline. We also model certificate cost across price and volume scenarios so it can be priced into customer contracts rather than absorbed.

Outputs

  • Recurring calculation process embedded in production reporting
  • Certificate cost modelled across price and volume scenarios
  • Contract and pricing implications quantified per customer

What good looks like

The ranges we design toward.

These are the improvement ranges these levers are known to produce where the underlying practice has not been examined recently. They are targets to test against your baseline, not promises.

Conservative

Default values by design

Defaults are set so that measuring is rewarded. Efficient producers are usually well below them.

Deductible

Domestic carbon price

Claimable against the obligation, but only with an evidence trail built before the fact.

Per product

Required granularity

Site-level averages do not satisfy the methodology. The calculation has to reach the goods themselves.

Deliverables

What you are left holding.

All of it handed over, documented, and with a session for whoever inherits it.
  1. 01Covered goods and obligation mapped precisely, including allocation of who bears it
  2. 02Product-level embedded emissions by production route, with documented allocation rules
  3. 03Deductible domestic carbon price quantified with a verifiable evidence trail
  4. 04Certificate exposure modelled across price and volume scenarios
  5. 05Recurring process embedded in production reporting rather than reconstructed each deadline

What an engagement looks like

A representative shape.

Illustrative. This is the shape of work in carbon trading, not an account of a specific client. We do not publish named results, and we would be wary of a firm that publishes them without the client in the room.

14 weeks

  1. 01Situation

    A cement producer entering the compliance market as an obligated entity could not say how short it would be at the first surrender date. The inventory had been built on spend factors, and a list of decarbonisation projects existed with no cost per tonne attached to any of them.

  2. 02What we did

    Rebuilt the inventory on activity data, costed every abatement option as levelised cost per tonne abated, and modelled the position across production, project-delivery and certificate-price scenarios to establish where abating stopped being cheaper than surrendering.

  3. 03Where it landed

    The rebuilt inventory moved the projected shortfall materially. Several measures abated below the plausible certificate price and went into the capital plan ahead of any purchase. Coverage for the remainder was scheduled through the year against a mandate with named ownership and transaction limits, rather than bought in a thin market in the closing weeks.

Where this connects

Rarely a self-contained problem.

These are the adjacencies that come up most often on this kind of work. Naming them is usually cheaper than discovering them halfway through.

Questions

The ones we get asked.

Is it worth measuring, or should we just use defaults?

Measure if you are reasonably efficient, which most modern plants are. Defaults are set conservatively so that measurement is rewarded, and the difference between a default and a real figure for a well-run facility is usually substantial and recurring. The measurement is also reusable for domestic compliance and customer disclosure, so it rarely stands on the CBAM saving alone.

We are a downstream producer. Are we covered?

It depends on the classification of the specific goods, and downstream coverage has been the most contested boundary of the mechanism. It is also a boundary that has moved and may move again. We establish your position against the current scope and flag where you sit close enough to a boundary that a future change would catch you, which is worth knowing before it happens.

How does the domestic carbon price deduction work in practice?

You evidence the carbon price effectively paid on the emissions embedded in those goods, and that it was not rebated or refunded. The mechanics depend on the domestic scheme's design. The practical point is that the evidence has to be constructed as production happens; it cannot be assembled retrospectively for a period whose records were never kept with this in mind.

Our customer is asking us to absorb the cost. Is that normal?

It is common and it is negotiable, and the negotiation goes better with a number. An exporter who can demonstrate embedded emissions below the default, with the deduction claimed, is arguing about a materially smaller figure than one working from defaults, and is often in a stronger position than a competitor who cannot produce the evidence at all.

Start a conversation

Talk to us about carbon border compliance.

Most useful first conversations are thirty minutes and involve no proposal. Describe the problem you are looking at and we will tell you honestly whether it is one we can help with.

Or write directly to hello@shyenova.com